The Great Inflation Identity Crisis

 

The Great Inflation Identity Crisis

If inflation had posted a social-media status update in 2020, it would have read: “It’s complicated.” The pandemic exposed a striking divide in the inflation story.

v  On one side was WPI, the wholesale world of factories, bulk buyers, industrial inputs, and wholesale trade. Here, the economy looked weak. Factories slowed, construction stalled, and business demand for raw materials, metals, fuel, and other inputs fell sharply. Bulk buyers were not exactly in a shopping mood when production lines were idle, and orders had dried up. With industrial demand collapsing, WPI inflation weakened and even turned negative in some months. The message from wholesale markets was basically: “No demand, no drama.”

But, Ghar se nikalte hi... Kuch durr chalte hi... the story changed. The moment goods left the factory gate and began their journey through transport networks, warehouses, and retail markets, they entered a very different world.

v  Lockdowns, transport bottlenecks, labor shortages, and supply disruptions made it harder to get essential goods to consumers. As a result, households found themselves paying more for vegetables, cooking oil, milk, and other necessities even while wholesale inflation remained weak. CPI inflation stayed elevated and at times exceeded the RBI’s upper tolerance limit.

The pandemic thus became a powerful lesson in inflation measurement. It showed that inflation is not a single, uniform experience across the economy; it depends on where prices are being measured. In normal times, the two often move broadly together. But when the economy breaks down in unusual ways during a period of severe disruption, they can sharply diverge. The lesson, then, was simple: the economy has more than one wallet.

v  The producer’s wallet got some relief because demand collapsed.

v  The household wallet got squeezed by supply disruptions.

And that is exactly why economists use more than one inflation index—because no single number can tell the whole price story.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

India’s Population: An Unfulfilled Promise in the Noisiest Democracy

  India’s Population: An Unfulfilled Promise in the Noisiest Democracy India proudly advertises its demographic dividend, i.e., millions of young hands, ready to work. But size has not become strength. The problem isn’t population; it’s potential trapped in policy paralysis . The Education Illusion: India is populous but not yet skilled. China’s villagers in the 1980s could run factories because they could read manuals. India liberalized first and educated later. Underfunded schools, social hierarchies, and elite indifference produced a workforce ready to hustle, but not to build. Today’s youth scroll reels between rejection emails while AI, automation, and gig work quietly raise the entry bar. Democracy Without Delivery: India democratized before it developed state capacity. With loud participation but weak execution, every reform meets a protest, a court stay, or a committee. Bureaucrats are rewarded for caution, not innovation. Whil...
Read more

A Very Fairly Unfair Story

  A Very Fairly Unfair Story Development, we’re told, is about achievement. In reality, it’s often a story of inheritance—of who began life with a head start and who was asked to treat disadvantage as character-building. When a child’s future depends less on effort than on family, caste, gender, or postcode , inequality doesn’t emerge —it arrives fully unpacked, with a welcome mat, in early childhood. Some children begin life with good schools, healthcare, nutrition, stable homes, and the assurance that one setback will not become a life sentence. Others begin with patchy schooling, unfair incomes, and the kind of adversity that gets politely filed under ‘ background conditions. ’ That is where the deeper unfairness lies. Not simply in unequal incomes or unequal outcomes, but in inequality of opportunity itself: in the unequal distribution of the conditions that allow effort to count in the first place. By the time society begins m...
Read more